Peppermint ice cream does two jobs in this punch. It supplies the mint and melts into the eggnog. Club soda loosens the mixture enough to ladle and gives each glass a foamy top. If you’ve been looking for something to serve with Christmas cookies, this is the drink to bring out when the cookie plate lands.
The recipe makes 16 servings of 3/4 cup each. Have a 4-quart punch bowl and a ladle ready. For an alcohol-free table, choose eggnog labeled alcohol-free. Jump to the printable peppermint punch recipe .
Get the glasses ready first

Spread the crushed peppermint candies on a plate. Wet the rim of each glass with water and dip it in the candy. Leave a few glasses plain for anyone who would rather skip the crunch. The ice cream gives even the plain glasses plenty of peppermint flavor.
Mix the punch when guests are ready

Use softened peppermint ice cream and keep the eggnog and club soda chilled until you need them. Set the ice cream and eggnog in the bowl, pour in the soda and stir gently. If you’re heading to someone else’s house, take the soda unopened and mix the bowl there. You’ll keep more of the fizz for the first glass.
Serve from the bowl

A 3/4-cup serving fits a small punch glass with room at the top. If you’d prefer a warm peppermint drink for the same cookie spread, try peppermint hot chocolate . For guests who want a fruit punch, there’s also a non-alcoholic Christmas punch .
For a long party, keep the dairy punch at 40°F or colder over ice. Discard punch left at room temperature for more than two hours, or one hour if the temperature is above 90°F. FDA buffet guidance

