Make this snowman cheese ball up to a month before Christmas and leave the face for party day. Under the white coating, the bigger cheese ball tastes of basil pesto. The head has grated onion, a dab of mustard and two drops of hot pepper sauce. Set a spreader beside him so the first guest can help themselves.

Shape the head and body ahead of time

Mix the softened blocks of cream cheese with the cheddar first. Divide that mixture into thirds, then combine two of them for the pesto body. Use the remaining third for the head. You’ll use the separate tub of whipped cream cheese later, once the snowman is standing on his plate.

Chill the two mixtures, covered, for about 4 hours. When each one holds its shape, roll it into a ball and wrap it separately. Label the packages before they go in the freezer so you can find both parts when you need them.

Cheese mixture shaped into a larger snowman body and a smaller head
Shape the body larger than the head so the snowman has a broad base.

When to thaw and frost the snowman

Allow about 12 hours for the wrapped balls to thaw in the refrigerator. For an evening party, move them from freezer to fridge that morning. The recipe’s 4 hours and 10 minutes covers prep and chilling before freezing. The thaw comes later.

Unwrap the body on the plate you’ll use for serving, then set the head on top. Spread softened whipped cream cheese over both balls with the back of a spoon. Leave the dip between the head and body visible so there’s a place for the scarf.

Two stacked cheese balls coated with whipped cream cheese
Frost the snowman on his serving plate so you can leave him there.

Give him a face and set out the crackers

Press chopped olive pieces into the coating for the eyes and buttons. A sliver of red bell pepper makes a mouth. Use a vegetable peeler to cut a long ribbon from a carrot, then drape it around the neck like a scarf.

Snowman cheese ball with olive buttons, a pepper smile and a carrot ribbon scarf
Press the decorations into the soft coating just before serving.

Put the crackers around the base after you’ve added the face. If the snowman is sharing the table with a Christmas tree charcuterie board , leave the spreader on the snowman’s plate so guests can cut into either flavor.

When the cheese ball comes out of the fridge, note the time. Discard it after two hours at room temperature, or one hour if it’s hotter than 90°F. FDA buffet guidance